Herbal Medicine Guide · Safety
Chinese Herbal Medicine Safety
Product quality, toxic and restricted substances, liver and kidney injury, pregnancy and interactions with medication.
Resource Hub / Herbal Medicine Guide / Chinese Herbal Medicine Safety
Key points
- Chinese herbs are pharmacologically active. Natural does not mean harmless.
- The most serious documented harms came from the wrong plant being used, from contamination and from products taken without supervision.
- The classical materia medica itself labels some substances as toxic and restricts how they are prepared and dosed.
- Herbs can interact with prescription drugs. Tell your physician and pharmacist about everything you take.
- Some classical ingredients are no longer used because they are toxic, come from protected species or are controlled substances.
Why safety needs its own page
The Herb Atlas and Formula Atlas are study references. They describe traditional use, including substances that are toxic or no longer used. This page collects the main safety issues in one place. It is general education and is not a guide to taking herbs.
Product quality and the wrong plant
One Chinese herb name can refer to more than one plant species, and similar names are used for unrelated plants. The best-documented disaster in herbal medicine came from this problem. In Belgium in the early 1990s, a manufacturing error in weight-reducing pills replaced Stephania tetrandra (Han Fang Ji) with Aristolochia fangchi (Guang Fang Ji), which contains aristolochic acid. More than 100 people developed progressive kidney disease (Debelle et al., 2008). Among 39 patients with end-stage kidney disease who had preventive surgery, 18 were found to have cancer of the urinary tract (Nortier et al., 2000).
Aristolochic acid nephropathy has since been reported around the world. Herbs known or suspected to contain aristolochic acid are no longer permitted in many countries, but cases continue where substitution occurs or where such products are sold online (Debelle et al., 2008). Three entries in the Herb Atlas carry this warning:
| Herb | Caution in the atlas |
|---|---|
| Han Fang Ji Stephania root | Must not be replaced with Guang Fang Ji (Aristolochia fangchi), which contains aristolochic acid. |
| Mu Tong Akebia stem | Only Akebia is used. Guan Mu Tong (Aristolochia manshuriensis) contains aristolochic acid and is prohibited. |
| Xi Xin Chinese wild ginger | Used in small doses. Only the root is used because the aerial parts contain aristolochic acid. Traditionally incompatible with Li Lu. |
Other quality problems include contamination with heavy metals or pesticides and adulteration with undeclared drugs. Products made under good manufacturing practice with species identification and batch testing reduce these risks. They do not remove the need for professional guidance.
Liver injury
Herbal and dietary supplements account for about 20% of liver injury cases recorded in United States research data. The main agents are anabolic steroids, green tea extract and multi-ingredient supplements (Navarro et al., 2017). Most of these are not classical Chinese formulas, but the finding shows that products sold as natural can injure the liver and that multi-ingredient products make the cause hard to trace. Within the Chinese materia medica, He Shou Wu has been associated with cases of liver injury, and several herbs carry classical warnings about overdose.
Signs that need prompt medical attention while taking any herb or supplement include yellowing of the skin or eyes, dark urine, unusual fatigue, nausea, abdominal pain and itching.
Ephedra
Ma Huang (ephedra) is the chief herb of several classical formulas for colds and wheezing. It contains ephedrine alkaloids, which raise heart rate and blood pressure. In 2004 the Food and Drug Administration declared dietary supplements containing ephedrine alkaloids adulterated because they present an unreasonable risk, which ended their sale as supplements in the United States (Food and Drug Administration, 2004). Formulas such as Ma Huang Tang appear in the atlas for study.
Substances the tradition itself calls toxic
Classical texts mark certain substances as toxic and specify processing, dose limits and combinations that reduce the risk. The atlas lists them with those warnings.
| Substance | Caution in the atlas |
|---|---|
| Gan Sui Kansui root | Toxic. Contraindicated in pregnancy. Traditionally incompatible with Gan Cao. |
| Jing Da Ji Peking spurge root | Toxic. Contraindicated in pregnancy. Traditionally incompatible with Gan Cao. |
| Yuan Hua Genkwa flower | Toxic. Contraindicated in pregnancy. Traditionally incompatible with Gan Cao. |
| Qian Niu Zi Morning glory seed | Toxic. Contraindicated in pregnancy. |
| Ba Dou Croton seed | Highly toxic. Historical reference only. |
| Shang Lu Poke root | Toxic. Contraindicated in pregnancy. |
| Bai Hua She Pit viper | Toxic. |
| Zhi Chuan Wu Prepared Sichuan aconite root | Toxic even when prepared and needs long cooking. Contraindicated in pregnancy. Traditionally incompatible with Ban Xia, Gua Lou, Bei Mu, Bai Ji and Bai Lian. |
| Ban Xia Prepared pinellia rhizome | The raw herb is toxic and only processed forms are taken internally. Used with care in pregnancy. Traditionally incompatible with aconite (Wu Tou). |
| Tian Nan Xing Prepared arisaema rhizome | Toxic when raw. Contraindicated in pregnancy. |
| Bai Fu Zi Prepared typhonium rhizome | Toxic. Contraindicated in pregnancy. |
| Fu Zi Prepared aconite accessory root | Toxic even when prepared and needs long cooking. Contraindicated in pregnancy. Traditionally incompatible with Ban Xia, Gua Lou, Bei Mu, Bai Ji and Bai Lian. |
| Quan Xie Scorpion | Toxic. Contraindicated in pregnancy. |
| Wu Gong Centipede | Toxic. Contraindicated in pregnancy. |
| Ku Lian Pi Chinaberry bark | Toxic. |
| Liu Huang Sulfur | Toxic when taken internally. |
| Lu Feng Fang Hornet nest | Toxic. |
A second group is described as slightly toxic or toxic in overdose: Cang Er Zi, Shan Dou Gen, Zao Jiao, Xing Ren, Bai Guo, Chuan Lian Zi, Shui Zhi, Tu Bie Chong, Wu Zhu Yu, Xian Mao, Rou Dou Kou, Guan Zhong.
Substances no longer used
Some ingredients of classical formulas are listed for historical reference only. Modern versions of those formulas leave them out or use substitutes.
| Substance | Status |
|---|---|
| Zhu Sha Cinnabar | Mercury sulfide, which is toxic. Listed for historical reference; not permitted in US products and left out of modern versions of classical formulas. |
| Chuan Shan Jia Pangolin scale | Pangolins are protected species. No longer used; Wang Bu Liu Xing or Zao Jiao Ci are substituted. |
| She Xiang Musk | Contraindicated in pregnancy. Natural musk comes from a protected species; synthetic muscone is used instead. |
| Ling Yang Jiao Antelope horn | The saiga antelope is endangered; goat horn (Shan Yang Jiao) is substituted. |
| Ying Su Ke Opium poppy husk | A controlled substance. Listed for historical reference and left out of modern versions of classical formulas. |
| Zi He Che Placenta | Listed for historical reference. |
Pregnancy
Classical texts list herbs that are contraindicated or used with caution in pregnancy. They are mainly herbs that strongly move blood, purge, drain downward or are toxic. In the Herb Atlas, 22 herbs are marked as contraindicated in pregnancy, including Tian Hua Fen, Da Huang, Mang Xiao, Lu Hui, Gan Sui, Jing Da Ji, Yuan Hua, Qian Niu Zi, Shang Lu, Zhi Chuan Wu, Tian Nan Xing, Dan Nan Xing, Bai Fu Zi, E Zhu. A further 32 are marked for avoidance or caution, including Gui Zhi, Mu Dan Pi, She Gan, Fan Xie Ye, Yi Yi Ren, Qu Mai, Ban Xia, Zao Jiao, Zao Jiao Ci, Hou Po. The absence of a warning in the atlas does not mean an herb is safe in pregnancy. Anyone who is pregnant, trying to conceive or breastfeeding should not take herbs without advice from their obstetric provider and a qualified herbalist.
Herbs and prescription drugs
Herbs can change how drugs work, and the reverse. Examples recorded in the atlas include Gan Cao (licorice), where long-term or high-dose use can cause fluid retention, low potassium and raised blood pressure, and Shui Zhi, which is contraindicated with anticoagulants. Blood-invigorating herbs in general call for care in people taking anticoagulant or antiplatelet medication.
Our Herb-Drug Interaction Checker lists documented cautions between common herbs and medications. It is a starting point for a conversation with your prescriber and pharmacist, not a substitute for one.
Classical combination rules
The tradition also records herb combinations to avoid, known as the eighteen incompatibilities and the nineteen antagonisms. These are explained on the principles page.
Practical points
- Do not choose herbs for yourself from an atlas, a symptom list or a product label.
- Give every clinician you see a full list of herbs, supplements and medications.
- Ask where a product comes from and whether it is tested for identity and contaminants.
- Stop the product and seek medical care if you develop new symptoms.
- Serious conditions need diagnosis and treatment by a physician. Herbal medicine is not a replacement for that care.
Looking for acupuncture or dry needling?
This herbal guide is for education. We do not prescribe herbal medicine at Morningside Acupuncture. Our licensed acupuncturists treat pain, sports injuries and stress with acupuncture and dry needling on the Upper West Side, in sessions of 45 to 60 minutes.
Book Your First VisitMore in the herbal medicine guide
References
Debelle, F. D., Vanherweghem, J. L., & Nortier, J. L. (2008). Aristolochic acid nephropathy: A worldwide problem. Kidney International, 74(2), 158-169. https://doi.org/10.1038/ki.2008.129
Food and Drug Administration. (2004). Final rule declaring dietary supplements containing ephedrine alkaloids adulterated because they present an unreasonable risk. Federal Register, 69(28), 6787-6854. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14968803/
Nortier, J. L., Martinez, M. C., Schmeiser, H. H., Arlt, V. M., Bieler, C. A., Petein, M., Depierreux, M. F., De Pauw, L., Abramowicz, D., Vereerstraeten, P., & Vanherweghem, J. L. (2000). Urothelial carcinoma associated with the use of a Chinese herb (Aristolochia fangchi). The New England Journal of Medicine, 342(23), 1686-1692. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM200006083422301
Bensky, D., Clavey, S., & Stöger, E. (2004). Chinese herbal medicine: Materia medica (3rd ed.). Eastland Press.
Chen, J. K., & Chen, T. T. (2009). Chinese herbal formulas and applications. Art of Medicine Press.
Scheid, V., Bensky, D., Ellis, A., & Barolet, R. (2009). Chinese herbal medicine: Formulas & strategies (2nd ed.). Eastland Press.
This page is for education. It does not diagnose or treat any condition and is not a substitute for care from a physician or a licensed practitioner. Do not take herbs without guidance from a qualified herbalist, especially if you are pregnant or take prescription medication.