The Balance Method Acupuncture (Dr. Richard Tan)

The Balance Method Acupuncture (Dr. Richard Tan) | Morningside Acupuncture NYC
Acupuncture Styles

The Balance Method: Richard Tan's Distal Acupuncture System, the Six Systems, Mirroring and Imaging, Main Texts, and Research

The Balance Method is a distal acupuncture system developed by Dr. Richard Teh-Fu Tan of San Diego. It treats pain by needling a "balancing" channel, usually on the opposite limb, chosen by a set of rules drawn from classical channel relationships. This guide covers its origins, the three-step "Acupuncture 1, 2, 3" process, the six systems, mirroring and imaging, its main texts and the limited research on it.

Hand holding a fine acupuncture needle
The Balance Method uses a small number of distal points.
Key Points
  • The Balance Method was developed by Richard Tan, who was influenced by Master Tung's acupuncture and published his first book, Twelve and Twelve in Acupuncture, with Stephen Rush in 1991 (Dong & Lee, 1992).
  • Treatment follows three steps: identify the affected channel, choose a balancing channel, then choose points by mirroring or imaging (Lotus Institute of Integrative Medicine, n.d.).
  • The balancing channel is chosen by six systems based on classical channel relationships, such as shared names, interior-exterior pairs and the Chinese clock (Bataille & Mitariu, 2020).
  • Needles are placed away from the painful area, often on the opposite limb, so the patient can move the painful area during treatment.
  • Published evidence is limited to descriptive articles and case reports.

New to Acupuncture?

See what a first visit involves, how long sessions run (45 to 60 minutes), and what treatment costs.

New Patients

Where the Balance Method Came From

Richard Teh-Fu Tan practiced and taught in San Diego, California. In his preface to the second edition of Master Tong's Acupuncture, he described using Master Tung's points and, in 1991, publishing Twelve and Twelve in Acupuncture with his longtime apprentice Stephen Rush (Dong & Lee, 1992). His approach simplifies classical channel theory into a practical method aimed mainly at pain (Lotus Institute of Integrative Medicine, n.d.).

Related Master Tung Acupuncture

Acupuncture 1, 2, 3

Tan summarized his method in three steps (Lotus Institute of Integrative Medicine, n.d.):

  1. Identify the affected channel. Find which channel or channels run through the area of pain.
  2. Choose the balancing channel. Use one of the six systems to pick a channel that "balances" the affected one.
  3. Choose the points. Use mirroring or imaging to find the matching area on the balancing channel, then palpate for the most tender spot to needle.

The Six Systems

Each system pairs channels using a relationship from classical theory (Bataille & Mitariu, 2020; Lotus Institute of Integrative Medicine, n.d.):

  • System 1, shared name: channels with the same name in the six-level system, such as hand tai yang (small intestine) and foot tai yang (bladder). Usually needled on the opposite side.
  • System 2, branching channels (bie jing): paired hand and foot channels of opposite names.
  • System 3, interior-exterior (biao li): paired yin and yang channels of the same organ system, such as lung and large intestine.
  • System 4, Chinese clock opposite: channels on opposite sides of the 24-hour "organ clock."
  • System 5, Chinese clock neighbor: channels next to each other on the clock.
  • System 6, same channel: the affected channel balanced by itself on the other side.

These are the tradition's rules for choosing points, not anatomical claims. A practitioner may combine more than one system in one treatment.

Mirroring and Imaging

  • Mirroring maps the arm onto the leg and back: the elbow corresponds to the knee, the wrist to the ankle and the fingers to the toes. Knee pain, for example, may be treated at the elbow.
  • Imaging maps the head and trunk onto the limbs, so that an area of the back or neck corresponds to a section of an arm or leg.

Source: Lotus Institute of Integrative Medicine, n.d.

Related Mirror Imaging and the Balance Method

How Distal Needling Might Work

In scientific terms, any effect of needling away from the painful area would act through the nervous system. Needling stimulates sensory nerves, which can engage pain-control pathways in the spinal cord and brain that reduce pain in other parts of the body. Moving the painful area during treatment may also change how the brain processes signals from that area. These mechanisms are supported for acupuncture in general but have not been tested for the Balance Method's specific rules.

The Balance Method Compared With Other Approaches
Balance MethodMaster TungTCM acupuncture
PointsClassical channel points and tender spotsTung's own point systemClassical channel points
How points are chosenSix systems plus mirroring and imagingTung's indications for each pointPattern diagnosis
Location of needles for painDistal, often opposite limbDistal, often opposite sideLocal and distal
Key textsTan & Rush, 1991; Tan, 2003Dong & Lee, 1992Cheng, 1987

The Main Texts

  • Twelve and Twelve in Acupuncture by Richard Tan and Stephen Rush, Tan's first book, focused on pain treatment with the Balance Method (Tan & Rush, 1991).
  • Twenty-Four More in Acupuncture by Tan and Rush, a follow-up to the first book.
  • Dr. Tan's Strategy of Twelve Magical Points, which uses one needle on each of the twelve channels for complex problems and gives clinical cases (Tan, 2003).
  • Acupuncture 1, 2, 3, Tan's summary of the three-step method.

What Research Shows

  • Descriptive review: a 2020 article in Medical Acupuncture describes the six systems and proposes combining the Balance Method with Japanese meridian therapy. It notes that results with the Balance Method can be unstable over time and offers this combination as a way to make effects last (Bataille & Mitariu, 2020).
  • Case report: a woman with nerve injury after wisdom tooth removal improved after three sessions that combined body and ear acupuncture with the Balance Method (Teja & Nareswari, 2021).

We found no controlled trials of the Balance Method. Its use rests on clinical experience and on the broader evidence that acupuncture can reduce chronic pain (Vickers et al., 2018).

The Balance Method: Summary of Sources
SourceTypeMain point
Tan & Rush, 1991BookFirst presentation of the method
Lotus Institute of Integrative Medicine, n.d.Training resourceThree steps, six systems, mirroring and imaging
Bataille & Mitariu, 2020Descriptive articleSix systems; combining with meridian therapy
Teja & Nareswari, 2021Case reportImprovement in post-surgical nerve pain
Guide Acupuncture Styles: The Complete Guide
Distal points on the hands and feet can be more sensitive than points elsewhere. Choose a licensed acupuncturist who uses sterile, single-use needles, and tell them about blood thinners, bleeding disorders, a pacemaker or pregnancy. Moving the painful area during treatment should stay within a comfortable range.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are the needles not where it hurts?

The Balance Method chooses a balancing channel, usually on another limb, and needles a matching area there. This leaves the painful area free to move during treatment.

Is the Balance Method the same as Master Tung acupuncture?

No. Tan was influenced by Master Tung and used some of his points, but the Balance Method is built on classical channel points and its own six systems (Dong & Lee, 1992; Bataille & Mitariu, 2020).

Does it work immediately?

Practitioners often ask patients to check their pain during treatment. Any change felt on the table is a short-term response; there are no controlled trials showing how long effects last.

Can it be combined with other styles?

Yes. Practitioners often combine it with local needling or other styles, and one published approach pairs it with Japanese meridian therapy (Bataille & Mitariu, 2020).

Related Meridian Therapy Acupuncture

Looking for Acupuncture or Dry Needling?

Morningside Acupuncture on the Upper West Side offers acupuncture and dry needling from New York licensed acupuncturists. See what a first visit involves and what treatment costs.

New Patients

References

  1. Bataille, B., & Mitariu, P. (2020). Japanese Acupuncture: A Complementary Approach to the Meridian Balance Method. Medical Acupuncture, 32(4), 194-200. https://doi.org/10.1089/acu.2020.1415
  2. Cheng, X. (Ed.). (1987). Chinese acupuncture and moxibustion. Foreign Languages Press.
  3. Dong, J., & Lee, M. (1992). Master Tong's acupuncture: An ancient alternative style in modern clinical practice. Blue Poppy Press.
  4. Lotus Institute of Integrative Medicine. (n.d.). Dr. Richard Tan's balance method. eLotus. https://www.mastertungacupuncture.org/node/4563
  5. Tan, R. T.-F. (2003). Dr. Tan's strategy of twelve magical points. Richard Tan.
  6. Tan, R. T.-F., & Rush, S. (1991). Twelve and twelve in acupuncture.
  7. Teja, Y., & Nareswari, I. (2021). Acupuncture Therapies for Addressing Post Odontectomy Neuropathy. Medical Acupuncture, 33(5), 358-363. https://doi.org/10.1089/acu.2020.1472
  8. Vickers, A. J., Vertosick, E. A., Lewith, G., MacPherson, H., Foster, N. E., Sherman, K. J., Irnich, D., Witt, C. M., Linde, K., & Acupuncture Trialists' Collaboration (2018). Acupuncture for Chronic Pain: Update of an Individual Patient Data Meta-Analysis. The Journal of Pain, 19(5), 455-474. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpain.2017.11.005
#BalanceMethod #DrTan #DistalAcupuncture #Acupuncture #UpperWestSide

Disclaimer: This web site is intended for educational and informational purposes only. Reading this website does not constitute providing medical advice or any professional services. This information should not be used for diagnosing or treating any health issue or disease. Those seeking medical advice should consult with a licensed physician. Seek the advice of a medical doctor or other qualified health professional for any medical condition. If you think you have a medical emergency, call 911 or go to the emergency room. No acupuncturist-patient relationship is created by reading this website or using the information. Morningside Acupuncture PLLC and its employees and contributors do not make any express or implied representations with respect to the information on this site or its use.

Theodore Levarda

Teddy is a licensed acupuncturist and certified myofascial trigger point therapist at Morningside Acupuncture in New York City.

Teddy specializes in combining traditional acupuncture with dry needling to treat pain, sports injuries, and stress.

https://www.morningsideacupuncturenyc.com/
Previous
Previous

Auricular Acupuncture (Ear Acupuncture)

Next
Next

Master Tung Acupuncture